Group Dynamics and Cognitive Biases of Auditors on Audiт Procedures (A Case Study at Moore Global Indonesia)
This study examines how group dynamics and cognitive biases existed in the planning and execution of audit procedures at Moore Global Indonesia (South Jakarta 2 Branch). An exploratory qualitative approach with a case study design was employed to investigate group dynamics and cognitive biases phenomena within a natural organizational setting. Primary data were collected through indepth semi-structured interviews with auditors across four hierarchical levels (Junior, Senior, Supervisor, and Manager), complemented by prolonged participant observation conducted over a one-year internship period. The data were analyzed using NVivo 15 software and triangulated with secondary data obtained from standard audit engagement documentation. The findings indicate that audit planning and execution are strongly shaped by hierarchical structures, where leadership influence, communication patterns, and supervisory interactions affect auditors' professional judgment. Cognitive biases manifest differently across audit phases: authority bias and anchoring bias are more prominent during the planning stage, whereas confirmation bias becomes more evident during the execution stage, particularly under time pressure and heavy workloads. Furthermore, repeated collaboration within stable audit teams may foster familiarity bias and groupthink, potentially reducing professional skepticism by encouraging consensus over independent critical evaluation. However, structured mitigation mechanisms (including analytical team discussions, multilevel supervisory reviews, and the consistent application of professional skepticism) help reduce cognitive biases. The study concludes that the effectiveness of audit procedures depends on maintaining an appropriate balance between hierarchical supervision, open communication, and the systematic management of cognitive biases within audit group dynamics.